IMA Senior Fellow in Pediatrics Dr. Katherine Welch joined The National News Desk after the United States lost the measles elimination status it had held since 2000. Dr. Welch explains that the designation simply means a single strain has circulated in the country for 12 consecutive months. She says it has nothing to do with how many cases there are or how serious they are, and notes that Canada and some European countries have already lost the same status.

Her advice to parents starts with a strong baseline of health and vitamin A, which she says multiple studies show protects against both infection and serious complications. She calls the MMR effective, but adds that it only comes as a three-in-one shot and that its package insert lists risks including encephalitis. What she offers families is informed consent: the information they need to weigh the risks and benefits for their own children. She also reminds viewers that measles deaths had already fallen dramatically before the vaccine arrived in 1963, which she credits mostly to sanitation, nutrition, and the population’s overall health.

Check out these related resources from IMA below, followed by the full segment transcript.

Transcript

Angela Brown: Well, the United States has lost its measles elimination status it’s held since 2000. That’s the big headline here. But what does it tell us about the chances of getting the measles where we live? And when families ask about the MMR vaccine, what do we know about the benefits and also the risks? Joining us now is Dr. Katherine Welch, Senior Fellow in Pediatrics with the Independent Medical Alliance. Good to talk to you again.

Dr. Katherine Welch: Good to be back here again. I’ll just say, I have these conversations daily with my patients.

Angela Brown: When it comes to the measles and the vaccine?

Dr. Katherine Welch: Yep.

Angela Brown: I’m curious to know what people are saying about it. Health officials found—this is what they’re saying about losing this elimination status—they found a chain of measles infections kept spreading in the U.S. for more than a year. I guess that’s the underlying reason. What do you want people to know right now who are watching this? Because when you hear “measles elimination status gone,” it immediately might send up a little bit of fear here.

Dr. Katherine Welch: Just to say, this elimination status just means there’s one single strain that’s been persistently circulating throughout the U.S. population for 12 consecutive months. It doesn’t have anything to do with the amount or number of cases. So you could have a couple hundred cases and have a single strain, and then we would technically lose that elimination status.

But we’ve had—other countries such as Canada lost theirs last year. Other European countries have lost their elimination status in recent years. It doesn’t have anything to do with the seriousness, doesn’t have anything to do with the number of cases or anything that’s clinically relevant for how we treat and identify measles.

Angela Brown: Did you say that we’ve lost our status before?

Dr. Katherine Welch: I cannot confirm that. I think we have, but if we have, it’s been a long time.

Angela Brown: Okay, let’s circle back to what you said at the beginning of this regarding parents that you’ve heard from who are coming in to talk to you. Now, measles cases are up nationally. We know that. If a parent is coming to you asking you questions, what type of things are you telling them? How do you break down what they should know about what’s happening in their community to understand the fact that these measles cases are up nationwide?

Dr. Katherine Welch: They’re up nationwide, and they’re up in Indiana, where I live. And so it’s important to know that parents can get some direct information from their public health information website. But I think it’s important to know that when you have a baseline of health, your terrain of your body to fight measles or any other infection, that’s really the most important thing to know.

It’s also important to know that vitamin A has been shown in multiple studies to be protective against not just getting the infection, but against serious complications and serious disease. And vitamin A is also a treatment for it, and you should ask your doctor. But vitamin A can be found in a standalone supplement or in cod liver oil, which also has vitamin D and other good stuff.

Angela Brown: Well, there is, of course, also a vaccine for it. You have the MMR vaccine. CDC says one dose of it is about 93%, I believe, effective at preventing the measles. With two doses, it is around 97% effective at preventing the measles. You say parents are coming in to you, they’re asking you questions about this. What are you telling them about the benefits and the risks?

Dr. Katherine Welch: Yes, so the MMR vaccine, you don’t separate out the measles, mumps, and rubella. There’s no single shot. So if you want the measles shot, you have to get all three. It is effective. However, there is risk to getting the shot as well. And so you’ll see in the package insert on the CDC website that there’s risk of encephalitis and fever and also mild other types of measles reactions and even death. And so there’s nothing that’s absolutely safe, and there’s nothing that’s absolutely without risk.

My parents are very smart, and they’re really weighing their risk. And so they want to know, because a lot of my parents actually have not had the MMR vaccine, and so they’re questioning again: Well, should we go visit? Are we revisiting this decision? Is this what we really need to do? And so I walk with them step by step. My point is informed consent, giving them the information that they need to have in order to weigh the risks and the benefits and what’s best for their family and their children.

Angela Brown: Well, how do you respond when people say the reason why these measles cases are going up is because people are not getting vaccinated?

Dr. Katherine Welch: Well, that may be true, but it also may be true that the vaccine does not give lifelong immunity. And so after generations of administering the vaccine, we are losing—there are more people not getting the vaccine, but I would say that it’s also a risk when you do vaccinate. And so, for example, congenital measles. We don’t have mothers with persistent antibodies, persistent protection against the measles. And so we are also having to give boosters. I remember when I was in high school, we had to give a booster because there was another outbreak.

I also want to bring people back to when we first started giving a vaccine in 1963. There was already a 99% reduction in measles incidences, and that was mostly because of the sanitation and nutrition and the overall health of our population. We were talking about cases in the hundreds of thousands, and now we have 5,000 cases this year.

Angela Brown: Well, I know that the CDC says the vaccine is effective, and for the most part, they say it works. It can help prevent people from getting the measles. Thank you for your time. For more information and resources, visit imahealth.org. Dr. Katherine Welch, Senior Fellow in Pediatrics with the Independent Medical Alliance. Thank you for joining us.

Dr. Katherine Welch: Pleasure.

IMA Logo white

Healthcare Reform—Powered by You 🤝

We’ve been working toward healthcare reform long before it made headlines. The Independent Medical Alliance brings together doctors, scientists, and advocates who believe patients should come first—and that belief is finally gaining ground.

But we can’t keep that momentum without you.

Donate today to help us protect principled, patient-centered care and push back against the forces trying to shut it down.