Saving Lives Should Not Require Permission

  • Saving Lives Should Not Require Permission

    Posted by IMA-HelenT on September 4, 2026 at 9:25 am EDT

    A choice is only free if you are allowed to choose the opposite.

    Isn’t that a great line?

    It came from an article about something completely outside medicine, but it immediately made me think about healthcare and the lack of real choice (freedom)

    That tension sits at the heart of Dr. Joseph Varon’s latest Brownstone article.

    He asks, why a doctor can be held responsible for what happens to a patient, why can that same doctor be told they cannot use their own clinical judgment because a hospital protocol, insurer or regulator says no?

    Read here: https://brownstone.org/articles/saving-lives-should-not-require-permission

    IMA-HelenT replied 1 month, 2 weeks ago 2 Members · 2 Replies
  • 2 Replies
  • Richard Mcadam

    Member
    September 4, 2026 at 12:06 pm EDT

    In the UK, in my opinion, protocol introduction was, from a healthcare point of view, a terrible idea, as I understand it, it took the clinical decision making out of the hands of the healthcare provider, to keep them within the boundaries of their medical insurance requirements, what could possibly go wrong became blatantly clear, when, in 2020, covid turned up, and what followed, was what could best be described as a disaster. In hindsight, it now makes sense why the politicians replaced Matron with 6 figure salaried management puppets who would do the politicians bidding, prior to this, the NHS ran like a Swiss watch, for a fraction of the cost, doctors were allowed to use their skills to assess their patient, and treat as they saw fit, I doubt Matron would ever have willingly agreed to the introduction of protocols.

    • IMA-HelenT

      Organizer
      September 4, 2026 at 1:03 pm EDT

      Thanks @richard mc … My mother trained to be a Sister in the NHS, and she always said the Matrons were the glue that held everything together. They knew the wards, they knew the staff, they knew the patients and, importantly, they had the authority to act when something wasn’t right.

      COVID certainly exposed how dangerous that can become when a protocol is treated as the answer rather than a starting point.

Log in to reply.